The I Thought - Ramana Maharshi

Written on April 7, 2008 by Tom Stine


Q: This ‘I’-thought rises from me. But I do not know the Self.

A. All these are only mental concepts. You are now identifying yourself with a wrong ‘I’, which is the ‘I’-thought. This ‘I’-thought rises and sinks, whereas the true significance of ‘I’ is beyond both. There cannot be a break in your being. You who slept are also now awake. There is no unhappiness in your deep sleep whereas it exists now. What is it that has happened now so that this difference is experienced? There was no ‘I’-thought in your sleep, whereas it is present now. The true ‘I’ is not apparent and the false ‘I’ is parading itself. This false ‘I’ is the obstacle to your right knowledge. Find out from where this false ‘I’ arises. Then it will disappear. You will then be only what you are, that is, absolute being.


Creative Commons License credit: jmsuarez
Posted in: Guru Quotes
Tagged with:
13 comments

Comments

Mark KrusenNo Gravatar  said
on April 8th, 2008 at 12:41 am


Tom, My fist inclination was to come back later and re read your post. “I” mean really. 2:36 am is pretty early to absorb what your writing. Especially with only one “eye” open. :)My false I tried to tell me to come back later. But the one that is slowing waking up, says. “Great post Tom,I’m looking forward to other comments on this post and will come back later.

Mark Krusen’s last blog post..Justa biting into an Elephant

ShadowduckNo Gravatar  said
on April 8th, 2008 at 9:52 am


Each time I read a quote like this, or anything on non-duality, I feel that I nearly - but not quite - grasp what it means. I can’t even point to which part doesn’t click with me, to ask for explanation. I understand what’s being said, but it itches at the back of my mind.

*sigh* Hopefully, someday I’ll manage to scratch that itch.

EvanNo Gravatar  said
on April 8th, 2008 at 6:54 pm


An absolute being that can’t think? Hmm

But if I question I’m guilty of thought and so must be wrong? Hmm

Evan’s last blog post..Big Benefits of a Little Exercise.

Tom StineNo Gravatar  said
on April 8th, 2008 at 8:38 pm


@Shadowduck Interesting, though, that something in your gets it. Something in you understands. These type of statements aren’t really meant for the mind. They are meant for that which knows, the itch at the back of your mind. That’s why I like them. :-)
@Evan There is nothing wrong with thought. Thinking is neither good nor bad. Thought just won’t tell you who you are. Ramana is pointing that the thought “I” is the thought that causes all the trouble. What you are is beyond the thought of who you are. So, you can think all you want. But just don’t believe what it tells you about who you are.

Mark KrusenNo Gravatar  said
on April 9th, 2008 at 7:18 am


Tom I agree with you when you say “there is nothing wrong with thought. Thinking is neither good or bad.”That leads me back to my own quote from 1970 that I may have borrowed at the time. “He who thinks has never really thought.Think about it!! It makes you think, doesn’t it.

Mark Krusen’s last blog post..You’ve Justa gotta be kidding me!

Tom StineNo Gravatar  said
on April 11th, 2008 at 5:30 pm


@Mark “He who thinks has never really thought.” You got it, Mark. That’s the idea. Thinking is just the noise between our ears.

DavidyaNo Gravatar  said
on April 18th, 2008 at 4:54 pm


@Tom Great quote, thanks. ‘I’ needed that. ‘I’ was just thinking about this. Then I saw the blog link under the other article. At first we seem to be the false ‘I’. The we wake up from that illusion. The ego, which has been pretending to be I, is shown for what it is. We find ourselves nyeti - not this. Gradually, what we are opens and moves forward. We drown in the ocean of love, then all of our world is lost in infinity. We wake up from the final illusion of the world.

Then the Upanishadic saying is true - I am That, Thou art That, All This is That. As the unity deepens, a new value emerges. Another surprise.

In quite a bit of the literature, people say things like “any teacher that says I am enlightened is not because they said I” I becomes the dirty word. (laughs) But heres the surprise - its back. Only now, ‘I’ is everything, unbroken, unbounded.

It illustrates from where Ramana Maharishi spoke.

(PS - Yogananda was the originator of the quote (without the because) in response to a reporter. I think his statement was directed more at enlightenment as a concept. Any concept of enlightenment is automatically wrong.(laughs) It is not something the mind can conceive. So teachers tend not to make claims like this.

PS - thanks for all the inspiration

Davidya’s last blog post..The evolving I

Tom StineNo Gravatar  said
on April 18th, 2008 at 5:09 pm


@Davidya Now you know why I do these quotes. They are useful and powerful.

As for the “you can’t be enlightened because you said “I am enlightened”: the first time I heard that I thought “what a crock of sh*t!” It was a semi-popular spiritual teacher who has had some experience with awakening. He goes to great lengths to say “this body-mind” instead of “I”. Ridiculous. I’m glad to know where it came from. And it is still a crock. The word “I” is completely empty, at least as it refers to the point in space called Tom or Davidya. It refers to nothing. Yet look at Nisargadatta. He’s saying things like “I’m everything.” He clearly means more than the little Indian man sitting on the rug.

All I can say is Words, Words, Words!! You can say whatever you want, because none of them are really true. Adya says, “all words are simply teaching strategies.” Much better! Or the Zen concept of two words canceling each other out like two arrows meeting in midair.

DavidyaNo Gravatar  said
on April 18th, 2008 at 5:27 pm


Well put, Tom. I do notice that the awake tend to be subtle about it, to try and circumvent concepts. Like Adya talks about his experience but doesn’t go making statements about it. Making postures and artificial avoidance points to self-concepts and an immature realization.

For some reason “All I can say is Words, Words, Words!! You can say whatever you want, because none of them are really true.” struck me as like words to a song. (laughs)

DavidyaNo Gravatar  said
on April 18th, 2008 at 5:37 pm


There is a deeper value to words though, one thats harder to see with English. Words have a meaning - and that is the part thats the illusion as it may not be the same meaning from one person to another. But words also have another characteristic - sound. Sound is vibration and it moves out and reverberates around. Vibration is the fundamental thing that expresses everything.

In Sanskrit (unlike most languages), there is a relationship between the sound of a word and its meaning (form). This draws the meaning much closer to sync with reality. Also, when things first express, they start as vibration alone, give rise to fields and so forth into expression. If one can be still and silent at that level of first vibration (called Ritam Bara Pragyan - that consciousness which accepts only truth), we can listen to sounds and they will trigger related forms. In other words, they are a way to codify and share experience. This is the hidden secret of Sanskrit chants. They are encoded experiences. Cool eh?

EvanNo Gravatar  said
on April 18th, 2008 at 7:00 pm


And yet you guys seem to be communicating fine with words.

Words are social as well as individual. Between everything and nothing there lies . . .

Evan’s last blog post..Blogs I Can Recommend

Tom StineNo Gravatar  said
on April 18th, 2008 at 7:23 pm


@Evan Excellent!! Thanks for pointing that out. As Nisargadatta Maharaj said, “And between these two my life turns.”

Trackbacks


Leave a reply

Name (required)
Email (will not be published) (required)
Website
1 + 2 = ? (anti-spam) (required)

 

 

 

Comment Guidelines: If you would like to leave a comment, even if you disagree with what I've written, that's great. Glad to have your views. If you leave a comment that includes a personal attack, say something demeaning to another person or use grossly inappropriate language, you will be bounced. So play nice!

Living from Consciousness Newsletter

Free! A newsletter filled with exclusive articles on living from consciousness, awakening and spirituality. Support yourself via your inbox several times each month. (And fear not, your email address is never sold or spammed.) Sign-up and receive a special bonus.





Best of Tom Stine


Recent Posts


Categories


Twittering...


Subscribe to Articles

  Get Articles by Email:


Tom Recommends


Guru Quotes

All of our thoughts are conditioned. We all are thinking exactly along the lines we are conditioned to think. Programmed like a computer. Anybody who thinks they are actually choosing of their own free will the line of thinking that they have is completely deluded by their thinking.


Behind most spiritual practices is the belief that you have to get someplace you’re not- a destination called realization or enlightenment. But realization isn’t someplace else; it’s the naturally occurring human state. It doesn’t belong to anybody. It’s who we all are. Spiritual practices also set up many pictures of what this state looks like. For example, when I described how much fear was present, people told me the fear meant that something must be wrong, because fear was an indication that I wasn’t in the proper state. But fear is just what it is, and it’s there too in the vastness of who we are.

In spiritual life there is no room for compromise. Awakening is not negotiable; we cannot bargain to hold on to things that please us while relinquishing things that do not matter to us. A lukewarm yearning for awakening is not enough to sustain us through the difficulties involved in letting go. It is important to understand that anything that can be lost was never truly ours, anything that we deeply cling to only imprisons us.

Those who awaken never rest in one place.
Like swans, they rise and leave the lake.
On the air they rise and fly an invisible course.
Their food is knowledge.
They live on emptiness.
They have seen how to break free.
Who can follow them?

We always want someone else to change so that we will feel good. But has it ever struck you that even if your wife changes or your husband changes, what does that do to you? You’re just as vulnerable as before; you’re just as idiotic as before; you’re just as asleep as before. You are the one who needs to change, who needs to take medicine. You keep insisting, “I feel good because the world is right.” Wrong! The world is right because I feel good. That’s what all the mystics are saying.